Compare motorcycle insurance quotes
Pick two or more companies to see rates where you live. Free, no obligation.
Agreed value vs. actual cash value
| Agreed value (classic policy) | Actual cash value (standard policy) | |
|---|---|---|
| Total-loss payout | The value you and the insurer agreed | Market value minus depreciation, decided after the loss |
| Restoration work | Reflected in the agreed value | Often undervalued |
| Rising collector values | Update the agreed value at renewal | May not reflect enthusiast market |
Who offers classic motorcycle cover
- Nationwide (with Hagerty): for motorcycles and scooters 25 years old or older. Its Guaranteed Value cover pays an agreed amount, there’s no fixed mileage limit, and it covers riding apparel such as jackets, gloves and helmets. It offers multi-vehicle discounts. Policies are underwritten by Essentia Insurance Company.
- Dairyland: offers agreed-value cover for vintage bikes 25 years or older.
- Specialist collector insurers may also insure motorcycles; compare usage rules and storage requirements.
Sources: Nationwide; Dairyland.
Typical eligibility conditions
Requirements vary, but insurers commonly look at:
- The bike’s age (often 25 years or older) or collector status
- Whether it’s a daily rider or used for pleasure, shows and club events
- Secure storage, such as a locked garage
- Your riding record and whether you have another vehicle for everyday use
Nationwide’s program allows flexible use without a fixed mileage cap, but other insurers may set limits, so ask.
How to set the agreed value
- Gather receipts for purchase, parts and restoration work.
- Take detailed photos of the bike from all sides and of any special features.
- Check recent sale prices for comparable bikes, or get a professional appraisal.
- Review the value every year, especially if the market or your bike’s condition changes.
Protecting a collector bike
- Storage: a locked, dry garage reduces theft and damage risk and may be required by the policy.
- Spare parts: rare parts can be expensive; ask whether spare parts and tools are covered.
- Shows and transport: check cover while the bike is on a trailer or displayed at events.
- Riding gear: Nationwide’s program includes apparel such as jackets, gloves and helmets.
- Restoration in progress: tell the insurer, because a partly restored bike may need a different value or cover type.
Classic vs. standard: which do you need?
If your older bike is a daily rider worth little, a standard policy, possibly liability-only, may be cheaper. If it’s restored, rare or worth more than book value, agreed-value cover is usually the better protection. See our coverage guide and insurer comparison. Classic Harleys are covered in our Harley-Davidson guide.
Frequently asked questions
What qualifies as a classic motorcycle for insurance?
Many insurers require the bike to be 25 years or older; Nationwide’s program uses that threshold.
What is agreed value motorcycle insurance?
Cover that pays a value you and the insurer agree when the policy starts, rather than a depreciated value after a loss.
Is classic motorcycle insurance cheaper?
Often, because collector bikes are ridden less and stored carefully, but it depends on the bike and insurer.
Are there mileage limits on classic motorcycle insurance?
It depends. Nationwide’s program has no fixed mileage limit; other insurers may set limits.
Can I ride my classic motorcycle every day?
Some classic policies restrict daily use. Check the usage terms before buying.
Sources
- Nationwide – Classic motorcycle insurance
- Dairyland – Motorcycle coverages
- Progressive – Motorcycle coverages
- MoneyGeek – Average cost of motorcycle insurance (Oct 2026)
Insurance prices, discounts and rules change often and vary by state. Figures were checked in October 2026; confirm details with the insurer or your state insurance department.